What I keep hearing from certain parts of our society is that Islam is evil and Muhammad was an evil pedophile because he married a nine-year-old. I don't know enough about the Qur'an and the traditional literature to know the details, but I can do research and ask the experts, and they say that's just another western
misrepresentation.
But even if she were nine, does that really make him and his religion evil, or just more open-minded? The
Journal of Homosexuality has produced many thorough studies on intergenerational / adult-child relationships, most notably in
this issue, although there
are occasionally
individual articles
on it. (If they don't get national acclaim, it's because of our repressive society's biases and ignorant fears, not because they have no value.) They show that, if people can overcome their biases and defy the stigma, there can be meaningful and productive adult-child relationships. In fact, it can be a source of comfort to be with someone more experienced, so you can avoid the anxiety of "not knowing what to do."
Yes, there are definitely abuses. Just like there are in
all types of relationships. But because one in four (or more) straight women are sexually abused, does that mean we should ban straight relationships? Plus, since we have defined
all adult-child relationships as abusive, even
relationships that continue into the younger partner's adulthood are stigmatized and deemed illegal, abusive, and rape. Until we realize that not all intergenerational sex is abusive, there can be no progress towards tolerance and acceptance.
People will say that the power imbalance is the issue. Good luck finding something without a power imbalance. Even in same-age, same-sex relationships, the only things without a built-in power imbalance, there's almost always one person more powerful than the other. If it's the person who brings home the higher income, or the person with a stronger or more manipulative personality, or the "butch" partner in relationships that work that way, or the one with a more secure life apart from the relationship, or anything else, someone is going to hold more power. You can't get away from it.
So? Abuse should be, and is, illegal. But don't call things evil and abusive just because they're outside your comfort zone and they are demographically similar to abusive relationships.